DAVID ALEXANDER BATEMAN
  • Home
  • About
  • Books
    • When the People Rule
    • Disenfranchising Democracy
    • Southern Nation
  • Articles and Chapters
    • Articles >
      • A Developmental Approach to Historical Causal Inference
      • A House Divided?
      • An Inherent Tension Within Populist Rhetoric
      • Deeper Roots
      • Democracy-Reinforcing Hardball
      • Democratization in the USA
      • Gilded Age Doughfaces
      • Ideal Points and American Political Development
      • Judicial Power and the Shifting Purpose of Article V
      • Partisan Polarization on Black Suffrage
      • Race, Party, and American Voting Rights
      • Southern Politics Revisited
      • The South in American Political Development
      • Transatlantic Anxieties
    • Chapters >
      • Election Administration and Democratic Fragility
      • Elections, Polarization, and Democratic Resilience
      • Race and Historical Political Economy
  • Working Projects
    • State Legislative Roll Calls
    • Congressional Data
  • Appointments
  • CV

A House Divided?
Roll Calls, Polarization, and Policy Differences in the U.S. House, 1877–2011

David A. Bateman, Joshua D. Clinton, and John S. Lapinski
​​
Abstract: The study of political conflict in legislatures is fundamental to understanding the nature of governance, but also difficult because of changes in membership and the issues addressed over time. Focusing on the enduring issue of civil rights in the United States since Reconstruction, we show that using current methods and measures to characterize elite ideological disagreements makes it hard to interpret or reconcile the conflicts with historical understandings because of their failure to adequately account for the policies being voted upon and the consequences of the iterative lawmaking process. Incorporating information about the policies being voted upon provides a starkly different portrait of elite conflict—not only are contemporary parties relatively less divided than is commonly thought, but the conflict occurs in a smaller, and more liberal, portion of the policy space. These findings have important implications for a broad range of work that uses elite actions to compare political conflict/polarization across time.

A House Divided? Roll Calls, Polarization, and Policy Differences in the U.S. House, 1877–2011
File Size: 795 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File


Replication Data
  • Home
  • About
  • Books
    • When the People Rule
    • Disenfranchising Democracy
    • Southern Nation
  • Articles and Chapters
    • Articles >
      • A Developmental Approach to Historical Causal Inference
      • A House Divided?
      • An Inherent Tension Within Populist Rhetoric
      • Deeper Roots
      • Democracy-Reinforcing Hardball
      • Democratization in the USA
      • Gilded Age Doughfaces
      • Ideal Points and American Political Development
      • Judicial Power and the Shifting Purpose of Article V
      • Partisan Polarization on Black Suffrage
      • Race, Party, and American Voting Rights
      • Southern Politics Revisited
      • The South in American Political Development
      • Transatlantic Anxieties
    • Chapters >
      • Election Administration and Democratic Fragility
      • Elections, Polarization, and Democratic Resilience
      • Race and Historical Political Economy
  • Working Projects
    • State Legislative Roll Calls
    • Congressional Data
  • Appointments
  • CV